Melissa Joan Hart's Sexy "Maxim" Shoot Sparked Threats of Being "Sued and Fired" From Teen Show
Christopher Duran
Updated on February 22, 2026
In the fall of 1999, Melissa Joan Hart was one of the busiest young stars in Hollywood. She had been starring in the TV series Sabrina the Teenage Witch since 1996, was about to see her rom-com Drive Me Crazy hit theaters, and had appeared in the video for "(You Drive Me) Crazy," Britney Spears' song for the movie's soundtrack. Yet even with all of this professional success, the star recently admitted that the day of the Drive Me Crazy premiere was "the worst day of [her] life."
During a recent appearance on the Boy Meets World rewatch podcast Pod Meets World, Hart revealed that, not only had she gone through a rough breakup that day, but she had also been told that her future at Sabrina was in jeopardy. The now-47-year-old said that her lawyer told her that she was in danger of being fired from the show and also sued, all over a provocative photoshoot she'd done for Maxim magazine. Read on to find out more.
RELATED: Former Teen Idol Says She Was Told Not to Hug Black Co-Star During '90s TV Special.
Hart was going through a lot the night of the premiere.
Hart was a guest on Pod Meets World due to her connections to the other teen show: She appeared on an episode and had a brief relationship with host and series star Will Friedle as a teen. Additionally, Sabrina and Boy Meets World were both part of ABC's TGIF lineup.
On the podcast, Hart was asked to reminisce about a photo of herself posing with Spears at the Drive Me Crazy premiere in 1999.
"If you look at my eyes and how red they are, I had been crying all evening," the actor said. She explained that she had just broken up with someone she was seeing, had been "up since 4 a.m." doing press for the movie, and had to wait on the red carpet for an hour until Spears arrived so they could take photos together.
Then, instead of watching the movie with the rest of the premiere attendees, she was driven to the airport to start work on the horror parody Scary Movie in Vancouvr. En route, she received a call that her role had been cut. Unfortunately for Hart, this wasn't the last of the day's bad news.
She was told she'd be fired from Sabrina.
After being let go from Scary Movie, Hart returned for the Drive Me Crazy premiere after-party. It was there that her lawyer approached her to talk about the repercussions of photos she had recently posed for.
"My lawyer shows up and goes, 'You did a photo shoot for Maxim magazine?'" the actor said. "I'm like, 'Yes, I did.' They're like, 'Well, you're being sued and fired from your show, so don't talk to the press, don't do anything.'"
Hart then heard from her mom, Paula Hart, who was the show's executive producer. "So I get a phone call on my cell phone from my mother, my producer, who's like, 'What did you do?'" Hart said. "And I was like, 'I don't know, whatever my publicist told me to do at the photo shoot. I did a photo shoot for Maxim. It's Maxim, of course you're gonna be in your underwear!"
For more celebrity news delivered right to your inbox, sign up for our daily newsletter.
She was told she was in breach of her contract.
On her Maxim cover, Hart is wearing underwear and holding a sheet up to cover her chest. The headline on the cover reads, "Sabrina: Your Favorite Witch Without a Stitch!" The actor, who was 23 at the time, said that this phrasing is what caused the potential legal issue. She explained that her contract with Archie Comics, on which the Sabrina show was based, prohibited Hart from ever appearing as the character naked or scantily clad. Despite the headline, the teen idol wasn't "playing" Sabrina in the Maxim photos; she had posed as herself.
Hart went on to say on the podcast that "nothing came of it" and that Archie Comics "had no ground to stand on" in order to fire her. She did write an apology letter, but the company did not take the issue further. She remained on Sabrina until it ended in 2003 after seven seasons.
RELATED: Former Child Star Danielle Fishel Says Exec Told Her He Had a Photo of Her in His Bedroom.
She thinks Archie Comics should have sued Maxim instead.
Hart talked about the "huge scandal" that was her Maxim shoot in 2019 on People Now.
"I had a contract with Archie Comics to say that I would never play Sabrina in her underwear, I would never be sexy Sabrina. And Maxim magazine, for some reason, put 'Sabrina' in big letters across the bottom, instead of 'Melissa' … So they wrote, 'Sabrina, your favorite witch without a stitch.' And so that went against my contract." She added, "Honestly, they should've sued Maxim."
Hart said she thought her "career was over" at the time. She continued, "It was very scary. Now, looking back, the controversy was: Am I allowed to be sexy at 23 years old while promoting a movie? Nowadays, it's like who's not sexy promoting a movie at 12?"
She also admitted to partying before the shoot.
Hart has also opened up about the day of the Maxim photo shoot, which she admitted she attended after a night out partying.
"The night before I went to my very first Playboy Mansion party. It was the Midsummer Night's [Dream] party, where you're in underwear," Hart said in a 2014 E! News interview. "So I was feeling a little shy, so I actually ended up rolling with some friends, doing some ecstasy, and going in a limo to my first Playboy Mansion party."
The actor explained that she didn't leave the party until very late, which made for a rough next day. "I think I rolled right up to the Maxim photo shoot, walked in, and was like, 'OK, so we're going to do this thing and go home?' And they're like, 'Oh no, girl, you're here for, like, 10 hours.'" she recalled.
Lia Beck Lia Beck is a writer living in Richmond, Virginia. In addition to Best Life, she has written for Refinery29, Bustle, Hello Giggles, InStyle, and more.Read moreFiled UnderCelebrities • Entertainment • NewsRead This NextThe Biggest '90s TV Teen Idols, Then and Now
Here's what the teen dreams you remember from your must-watch shows look like today.January 19, 2023'90s Teen Idol Was High During Popular Movie
"At the time, when we were shooting that, I was the world's biggest stoner."November 3, 2022"Boy Meets World" Stars Haven't Spoken in Years
Will Friedle, Danielle Fishel, and Rider Strong say the actor suddenly stopped talking to them.June 29, 202310 Things You Didn't Know about Justin Trudeau
Athlete, nerd, hopeless romantic, thespian. Yes, there’s a lot more to Canada’s Prime Minister than just politics.March 21, 2017Jon Hamm: The Best Life Interview
Jon Hamm, star of TV's Mad Men, reveals the secrets of manliness in a postmodern world.November 15, 2016Driving Tips Smart Men Know
Ten easy ways to be the safest driver on the road. April 3, 2017Men Who Set the Time: Cash Warren
The successful producer, entrepreneur and husband of Jessica Alba reveals how you, too, can live your best life.October 31, 2016Dr. Oz: The Best Life Interview
Mehmet Oz, M.D., asks the toughest question: Are you living or dying?October 23, 2016Dr. Oz's 15 Best Life Tips
October 23, 2016The One That Got Away
A single nutrient—omega-3 fatty acids—may have turned early humans into civilized man. Has stripping it from our diet given rise to cancer, diabetes, and other civilized diseases? Our correspondent investigates.February 23, 2017
